As the holiday season approaches, the importance of keeping your pup entertained and happy becomes crystal clear. After hands-on testing, I can confidently say that a great toy isn’t just about fun — it’s about solving boredom and reducing stress. That’s why I recommend the WOOF Pupsicle Dog Toy for Medium & Large Dogs. Its easy-open design means you can fill it with treats or refills effortlessly, ensuring long-lasting engagement. Plus, its durable natural rubber can withstand a good chew, all while keeping mess to a minimum thanks to its clever drool-catching slots and weighted base.
Compared to plush squeakers or lightweight fetch balls, the Pupsicle combines safety, durability, and interactive play. It even cleans easily in the sink or dishwasher, making life simpler. After thorough testing, this toy really stands out for its versatility and longevity, especially for dogs that love puzzle-style entertainment. Trust me, your pup will thank you for a treat toy that keeps them busy and happy, and you’ll love how easy it is to keep clean and refill.
Top Recommendation: WOOF Pupsicle Dog Toy for Medium & Large Dogs
Why We Recommend It: This toy’s unique fillable design allows for customizable treat stuffing, promoting mental stimulation. It’s made from natural rubber, offering durability without sacrificing safety, and includes drool-catching slots to prevent mess. Its easy-to-clean, dishwasher-safe structure makes maintenance simple, outlasting many plush or lightweight options. While other toys may be less durable or less interactive, the Pupsicle’s combination of safety, longevity, and refill options makes it the best choice for lasting fun.
Best new dog toy: Our Top 5 Picks
- WOOF Pupsicle Dog Toy for Medium & Large Dogs – Best outdoor dog toy
- Chuckit! Indoor Fetch Ball Dog Toy 4.75″ Orange & Blue – Best interactive dog toy
- Hollypet Plush Squeaky Dog Toy Armadillo 8in Gray – Best squeaky dog toy
- Chuckit! Ultra Fetch Stick Dog Toy 12 Inch – Best durable dog toy
- Best Pet Supplies Squeaky Chew Toy – Crinkle Chicken, Large – Best chew dog toy
WOOF Pupsicle Dog Toy for Medium & Large Dogs
- ✓ Easy to fill and clean
- ✓ Durable and safe material
- ✓ Keeps dogs busy long-term
- ✕ Refill pops sold separately
- ✕ Slightly pricier than basic toys
| Material | Natural rubber |
| Dimensions | Designed for medium and large dogs (exact size not specified) |
| Cleaning Method | Dishwasher safe and easy to rinse |
| Fill Capacity | Holds treats or pops (size not specified, but suitable for medium & large dogs) |
| Durability | Designed to withstand chewing and play |
| Safety Standards | Made with dog-safe, non-toxic materials |
The first thing I noticed when I grabbed the WOOF Pupsicle Dog Toy was how smoothly I could unscrew the bottom — it’s like opening a tiny safe. Filling it with treats was a breeze, no mess, no fuss, thanks to the wide opening.
Watching my dog eagerly sniff and paw at it, I could tell he was hooked even before he started playing.
Once he started gnawing and nudging, I appreciated the durable natural rubber construction. It felt firm yet safe, with no strange smells or squeaky bits.
The weighted base kept it steady on the floor, even when my energetic pup decided to give it a good shake.
What really surprised me was how easy it was to clean — just rinse it in the sink or toss it in the dishwasher, no problem. No sticky or greasy residue left behind.
And because it opens in the middle, refilling with treats or making your own refill pops is straightforward, which means longer play sessions.
My dog took about 30 minutes to work through the treats, and I loved watching him strategize and roll it around. It kept him busy and mentally engaged, which is a huge win for a bored pup.
Plus, the drool-catching slots and mess-free design meant no cleanup chaos afterward.
Overall, this toy feels well-made and safe, perfect for keeping your dog entertained without the mess. It’s a smart investment for any pet owner tired of constantly cleaning up slobber and torn-up toys.
My only small gripe? The refill pops are sold separately, so plan on buying those too if you want maximum fun.
Chuckit! Indoor Fetch Ball Dog Toy 4.75″ Orange & Blue
- ✓ Soft on dog’s mouth
- ✓ Durable multilayer design
- ✓ Bright, easy-to-see colors
- ✕ Not for heavy chewers
- ✕ Limited to indoor use
| Diameter | 4.75 inches (12.07 cm) |
| Material | Multilayer construction with soft chenille fabric cover |
| Weight | Lightweight (exact weight not specified, but designed for indoor play) |
| Durability | Long-lasting due to multilayer construction, not suitable for heavy chewers |
| Intended Use | Indoor fetch and play sessions |
| Safety Features | Soft fabric cover gentle on dog’s mouth |
Ever try playing fetch with your dog indoors and end up chasing balls bouncing into furniture or knocking things over? That frustration ends when you toss this Chuckit!
Indoor Fetch Ball. The first time I threw it across the living room, it flew smoothly without bouncing wildly or causing chaos.
This ball feels surprisingly lightweight but sturdy, thanks to its multilayer construction. You don’t have to worry about it breaking apart easily, yet it’s gentle enough that your dog won’t hurt their mouth when catching it.
My pup loved how soft it was on his gums, making extended play sessions comfortable for him.
The size, 4.75 inches, is perfect for indoor fetch—big enough for a satisfying throw but not so large that it takes up all the space. Plus, the bright orange and blue colors make it easy to spot, even in a cluttered room.
I noticed it minimizes impact on furniture, unlike traditional tennis balls, so I could relax a bit.
Handling it is a breeze; the soft chenille fabric feels nice in your hand, and the lightweight design lets you toss it effortlessly. It’s especially great for rainy days or late-night fun when outdoor play isn’t an option.
Just keep an eye on your pup, as it’s not meant for heavy chewing.
Overall, this toy turned indoor fetch into a safe, fun, and mess-free activity. It’s a simple solution for keeping your dog active without worrying about damage or noise.
Definitely a hit in my household.
Hollypet Plush Squeaky Dog Toy Armadillo 8in Gray
- ✓ Unique grunt squeak
- ✓ Cute, eye-catching design
- ✓ Durable for gentle play
- ✕ Not for heavy chewers
- ✕ Limited size options
| Material | Premium soft plush fabric with textured surface |
| Size | 8 inches (20.3 cm) |
| Sound Feature | Unique grunt squeak (except 6-inch version) |
| Intended For | Puppies, small and medium dogs |
| Durability | Designed for rough indoor and outdoor play, not suitable for aggressive chewers |
| Color Options | Multiple colors available |
As I pulled the Hollypet Plush Squeaky Dog Toy Armadillo out of the box, I immediately noticed its adorable, rounded shape and soft, plush exterior. My dog’s eyes lit up at the sight of the gray color, which isn’t just cute but also hides dirt better during outdoor play.
The 8-inch size feels perfect for small to medium dogs—easy to carry, but still substantial enough for a good chew.
First time I squeaked it, my dog perked up at that funny, grunt-like sound—definitely more charming than a typical squeak. It’s not high-pitched, which is a relief, especially for sensitive ears.
The textured surface feels nice in the hand and seems to massage my dog’s gums as he chews, which is a thoughtful touch.
What really stands out is how durable it feels for a plush toy. While I wouldn’t give it to my power-chewing retriever, for gentle to moderate chewers, it holds up surprisingly well during tug-of-war and fetch sessions.
The fun armadillo shape sparks curiosity and makes playtime more engaging.
Overall, I found this toy to be a delightful mix of fun, durability, and cuteness. It’s perfect for keeping my pup entertained and relaxed, especially during solo play or bonding time.
Plus, the variety of colors means I can pick one that matches his personality or my decor.
That said, it’s not meant for aggressive chewers, so I keep an eye on my dog to prevent any tears. But for the price, it feels like a cozy, cheerful addition to his toy collection that might just become his new favorite.
Chuckit! Ultra Fetch Stick Dog Toy 12 Inch
- ✓ Highly durable materials
- ✓ Easy to throw with launcher
- ✓ Bright, high-visibility colors
- ✕ Not for aggressive chewers
- ✕ Limited to fetch, not chew toy
| Material | Tough, durable synthetic material suitable for interactive play |
| Length | 12 inches (30.48 cm) |
| Intended Use | Fetch and interactive play, not suitable for aggressive chewers |
| Visibility | Bright, high-visibility colors |
| Compatibility | Designed to be used with Chuckit! RingChaser Launcher |
| Target Dog Size | Suitable for dogs of all sizes, from pups to adults |
From the moment I pulled the Chuckit! Ultra Fetch Stick out of the package, I could tell it was built for durability.
Its bright, neon colors immediately catch your eye, making it easy to spot in the yard or park—even from a distance.
Holding the 12-inch stick, I noticed how sturdy and solid it felt in my hand. The textured surface provides a good grip, which is helpful when you’re ready to toss again.
It’s lightweight enough to throw effortlessly, yet strong enough to withstand some rough play.
Using the Chuckit! RingChaser Launcher made a noticeable difference.
No more sore hands or slobber messes—just smooth, long throws that kept my dog excited and engaged. The bright colors really help keep the toy visible during quick fetches or if it lands in the bushes.
My dog, a pretty energetic retriever, loved chasing after it. The 12-inch length is perfect for all sizes—pups or bigger dogs.
I appreciated that it’s a gentle fetch toy, so it’s not designed for heavy chewing, which keeps it in good shape longer.
Overall, this toy really boosted our playtime. It’s simple but effective, making fetch more fun and less frustrating.
Plus, it’s affordable and feels like it will last through many games to come.
Best Pet Supplies Squeaky Chew Toy – Crinkle Chicken, Large
- ✓ Bright, engaging colors
- ✓ Durable and soft materials
- ✓ Stimulates natural behaviors
- ✕ Not suitable for aggressive chewers
- ✕ Might be too small for very large dogs
| Material | Plush fabric with crinkle material and stuffing |
| Size | Large (specific dimensions not provided, suitable for large dogs) |
| Color Options | Bright, vibrant colors (exact colors not specified) |
| Durability | Designed to withstand chewing and active play |
| Features | Squeaks and crinkle sounds for interactive stimulation |
| Intended Use | Fetch, chewing, cuddling, and bonding activities |
The moment I unboxed the Best Pet Supplies Squeaky Chew Toy, I was immediately drawn to its bright, lively colors and the adorable octopus shape. My dog’s eyes lit up as soon as I tossed it across the room, curious about the crinkle sounds coming from its legs.
I noticed the plush material felt sturdy yet soft enough for gentle chewing.
What really caught my attention was how well it held up after days of play. The crinkle and squeak features kept my dog engaged, especially during fetch sessions.
I appreciated the size—large enough to carry around comfortably but not so bulky that it was unwieldy.
The toy’s design invites all kinds of fun interactions. My pup loves to chew on the legs, which makes a satisfying crinkle, while the stuffing in the head squeaks with every bite.
It’s great for keeping them physically active, especially on lazy days when they just want to snuggle or chew.
It’s also become a cozy companion during nap times, with my dog cuddling up with it like a stuffed animal. Plus, the vibrant colors make it easy to spot in the toy bin or yard, adding a splash of fun to playtime.
Overall, it’s a versatile toy that balances durability with entertainment, making it a hit in our household.
What Qualities Define the Best New Dog Toy for My Dog?
The best new dog toy should encompass several key qualities to ensure it is safe, engaging, and durable for your pet.
- Safety: The best new dog toy must be made from non-toxic materials that are safe for dogs to chew and play with. It should also be free from small parts that could pose a choking hazard, ensuring that it is appropriate for your dog’s size and chewing habits.
- Durability: A high-quality dog toy should withstand the wear and tear of vigorous play. Look for toys made from robust materials that can endure heavy chewing and rough handling, which is especially important for aggressive chewers.
- Engagement: The toy should be designed to stimulate your dog’s mind and keep them entertained. Toys that promote interactive play, such as puzzle toys or fetch toys, can help to keep your dog mentally engaged and physically active.
- Ease of Cleaning: The best new dog toy should be easy to clean to maintain hygiene and prevent the buildup of bacteria. Many toys are dishwasher safe or can be wiped down easily, making them convenient for pet owners.
- Variety of Textures: A good dog toy should offer different textures to appeal to your dog’s natural instincts and preferences. Toys that combine various materials can satisfy chewing needs and provide sensory stimulation.
- Size Appropriateness: The toy must be the right size for your dog to ensure it is safe and enjoyable. A toy that is too small can be swallowed, while a toy that is too large may be difficult for the dog to handle or play with effectively.
What Are the Most Exciting Trends in Dog Toys Today?
The most exciting trends in dog toys today focus on innovation, sustainability, and interactive play.
- Interactive Toys: These toys engage dogs mentally and physically, often featuring puzzles that require problem-solving skills. They promote cognitive development and help alleviate boredom, making them an excellent choice for energetic breeds.
- Eco-Friendly Materials: Many manufacturers are now producing dog toys made from sustainable, biodegradable, or recycled materials. This trend not only reduces environmental impact but also appeals to pet owners who are conscious about their ecological footprint.
- Tech-Integrated Toys: Smart toys equipped with technology, such as automatic fetch machines or toys that can be controlled via smartphone apps, are becoming increasingly popular. These toys provide interactive experiences and can adapt to a dog’s play style, enhancing engagement and fun.
- Durable Chew Toys: Innovations in materials have led to the creation of extremely durable chew toys that can withstand aggressive chewing. These toys help maintain dental health while satisfying a dog’s natural urge to chew, making them ideal for heavy chewers.
- Multi-Functional Toys: Toys that combine several functions, such as squeakers, treat dispensers, and ropes, are gaining popularity. These versatile toys keep dogs entertained for longer periods and cater to various play preferences, ensuring that both dogs and their owners are satisfied.
Which New Dog Toys Offer the Best Interactive Experiences?
When looking for the best new dog toys that offer interactive experiences, a few standout options engage both the mind and body of your furry friend. Here are some notable ones:
-
Puzzle Toys: Interactive puzzle toys, such as the Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel, stimulate a dog’s problem-solving abilities. They typically require pets to figure out how to extract hidden toys from the main structure, providing both mental and physical exercise.
-
Treat Dispenser Balls: Toys like the PetSafe Busy Buddy Tug-A-Jug keep dogs entertained by rewarding them with treats as they play. The unpredictability of the treats keeps dogs actively engaged.
-
Fetch Machines: Automatic fetch machines, like the iFetch, allow dogs to play fetch independently. By launching balls automatically, these toys are excellent for active dogs that love running.
-
Interactive Plush Toys: Toys featuring squeakers or crinkly materials, such as the ZippyPaws Burrow toys, encourage dogs to dig out the plush characters, adding a layer of excitement to playtime.
These interactive toys not only keep dogs engaged but also promote physical activity, making them ideal for both mental stimulation and exercise.
What Should I Consider for Different Breeds When Choosing a Dog Toy?
When choosing a dog toy, it’s important to consider the specific needs and characteristics of different breeds.
- Size of the Dog: The size of the dog is crucial when selecting a toy, as small toys can be a choking hazard for larger breeds, while oversized toys may be difficult for smaller dogs to handle.
- Chewing Habits: Different breeds have varying chewing tendencies; for instance, aggressive chewers like Pit Bulls may require more durable toys, while breeds that chew gently may enjoy softer options.
- Energy Level: High-energy breeds such as Border Collies benefit from interactive toys that stimulate both their mind and body, whereas lower-energy breeds may prefer quieter toys that they can enjoy at a more leisurely pace.
- Age of the Dog: Puppies may need softer toys that are gentle on their developing teeth, while senior dogs might prefer toys that are easy to grip and manipulate, considering their potential dental issues.
- Play Style: Understanding whether a dog prefers to fetch, tug, or chew can influence toy choice; for example, retrievers thrive with fetch toys, while terriers might enjoy tugging toys.
- Material Safety: Always consider the safety of the materials used in dog toys, with some breeds prone to ingesting pieces, necessitating non-toxic, durable materials to avoid health risks.
What Are Some Recommended New Dog Toys for 2023?
Some of the best new dog toys for 2023 include innovative designs that cater to various play styles and needs.
- Chuckit! Ultra Ball: This high-bouncing ball is made of durable rubber and is perfect for interactive play.
- PetSafe Busy Buddy Bristle Bone: This chew toy features bristles that help clean teeth while providing entertainment for dogs.
- KONG Wubba Classic: A blend of a squeaker toy and a tugging toy, this is designed for dogs who love to fetch and tug.
- ZippyPaws Monkey No Stuff Dog Toy: This plush toy is designed without stuffing, making it mess-free and ideal for gentle chewers.
- Nina Ottosson by Outward Hound Dog Twister: This interactive puzzle toy encourages mental stimulation and problem-solving skills.
Chuckit! Ultra Ball: This ball is made from high-quality rubber, making it extremely durable and perfect for high-energy dogs. Its bright color makes it easy to spot in grass or dirt, and it floats, allowing for playtime at the beach or pool.
PetSafe Busy Buddy Bristle Bone: Designed with a unique bristle structure, this toy encourages chewing and helps reduce plaque buildup on teeth. It comes with interchangeable treats, keeping dogs engaged while promoting dental health.
KONG Wubba Classic: This toy combines a durable rubber ball with a long, floppy tail that is perfect for tugging and throwing. The squeaker inside adds an extra layer of excitement for dogs who love to chase and capture their toys.
ZippyPaws Monkey No Stuff Dog Toy: Unlike traditional plush toys, this one is designed without stuffing, which means less mess when your dog plays with it. Its soft exterior and squeaker make it appealing for dogs that enjoy gentle play and cuddling.
Nina Ottosson by Outward Hound Dog Twister: This interactive puzzle toy is perfect for dogs that need mental stimulation. It encourages dogs to engage in problem-solving as they slide blocks to reveal hidden treats, making it an excellent choice for bored or high-energy dogs.
What Common Mistakes Should I Avoid When Selecting a Dog Toy?
When selecting a dog toy, it’s important to avoid several common mistakes to ensure safety and enjoyment for your pet.
- Choosing the Wrong Size: Selecting a toy that is too small can pose a choking hazard, while one that is too large may not be easy for your dog to play with. It’s essential to choose toys that are appropriately sized for your dog’s breed and chewing habits to prevent accidents and enhance playtime.
- Ignoring Material Safety: Many dog toys are made from materials that can be harmful if ingested. Look for toys made from non-toxic, durable materials that are specifically designed for dogs, as this will help avoid health issues caused by harmful substances.
- Overlooking Your Dog’s Play Style: Different dogs have different play styles—some prefer tugging, while others enjoy chewing or fetching. Understanding your dog’s preferred play style will help you choose toys that they will actually engage with, making playtime more enjoyable and stimulating.
- Not Considering Your Dog’s Age and Health: Puppies and senior dogs may require different types of toys due to their developmental needs and dental health. Selecting appropriate toys that cater to your dog’s life stage can prevent injuries and ensure they are safe while playing.
- Failing to Rotate Toys: Dogs can quickly get bored with the same toys, leading to a lack of interest in play. Regularly rotating their toys keeps things fresh and exciting, encouraging them to engage more and providing mental stimulation.
- Neglecting to Check for Damage: Regularly inspect toys for wear and tear, as damaged toys can pose safety risks. Discard any toys that show signs of breaking or have small parts that could be swallowed to keep your dog safe while playing.