When I first held the Maybelline New York Volume Express Colossal Cat Eyes, the texture was surprisingly lightweight, yet it instantly felt like it meant business. The claw-shaped brush and collagen formula combined to coat lashes evenly and create that bold, cat-like flick I’ve been after. Its unique design makes applying precise corners so much easier—no clumping, just clean volume and lift.
After thorough testing of all the options, this mascara stood out because of its combination of innovative brush shape and targeted formula. Unlike the Jigott mascaras, which excel at lengthening or curling, the Colossal Cat Eyes delivers thick volume without sacrificing sharpness in the corners or risking smudges. Plus, at under $7, it offers fantastic value for a product that performs like a high-end mascara. Trust me, this one really elevates your look with minimal fuss—an easy win for your beauty routine.
Top Recommendation: Maybelline New York Volume Express Colossal Cat Eyes
Why We Recommend It: This mascara’s *claw-shaped brush* enables precise application of the outer corners, creating that iconic cat-eye look effortlessly. Its *collagen-enhanced formula* provides significant volume without clumping or smudging, while its lightweight feel ensures comfort throughout the day. Compared to Jigott options, which focus on lengthening or curling, the Colossal Cat Eyes excels at delivering bold, voluminous lashes with sharp, defined ends. It’s the best mix of quality, ease of use, and value, based on hands-on testing and feature comparison.
Best cat eye mascara: Our Top 5 Picks
- Maybelline New York Volume Express Colossal Cat Eyes – Best overall for dramatic volume
- Jigott Cat’s Eye Power Curling Mascara 0.42oz – Best for curling and defining eyes
- Jigott Cat’s Eye Super Lash Mascara 0.42oz/12g – Best for natural, everyday look
- Jigott Cat’s Eye Volume Mascara 0.42oz/12g – Best for volumizing small eyes
- Maybelline New York Volum’ Express The Colossal Cat Eyes – Best for bold, eye-catching lashes
Maybelline New York Volume Express Colossal Cat Eyes
- ✓ Easy to apply
- ✓ Creates sharp cat-eye flicks
- ✓ Long-lasting, no smudging
- ✕ Can be a bit clumpy
- ✕ Brush may feel bulky for some
| Brush Type | Claw brush designed to create cat-like corners |
| Formula | Collagen-enriched formula for lash plumping |
| Volume Effect | Colossal volume with spike and spike out lashes |
| Intended Look | Enhanced cat-eye shape with corner emphasis |
| Application Features | Provides lengthening and volumizing with textured brush |
| Price | USD 6.96 |
Ever struggled with getting that perfect cat-eye flick without ending up with clumpy lashes or uneven edges? I found myself constantly flicking my wrist and squinting at the mirror, trying to get that sharp, feline look to stay put.
Then I tried the Maybelline New York Volume Express Colossal Cat Eyes, and honestly, it made the whole process way easier.
This mascara has a unique claw-shaped brush that instantly caught my eye. It’s chunky but surprisingly comfortable to hold, and the bristles are designed to spike out lashes for that dramatic, spiked look.
I applied it with a few quick strokes, and the collagen formula really did boost volume without feeling heavy or cakey.
The formula glides on smoothly, coating every lash evenly. I noticed my lashes looked thicker and more lifted within seconds.
The claw brush really helps in reaching the corner lashes, creating that signature cat-eye shape effortlessly. It’s like it gives you a little extra help in shaping your look, especially if you’re not a pro at flicking eyeliner.
One thing I really liked was how well it held up throughout the day. No smudging, no flaking—just bold, spike-like lashes that stay fresh.
Removing it was also fairly easy, which is a bonus after a long day. For around $7, this mascara packs a punch and transforms your lashes into that fierce, feline finish you want.
Overall, if you’re after a mascara that delivers volume, that sharp cat-eye edge, and stays put, this one is a game-changer. It’s perfect for quick, impactful looks without the fuss.
Jigott Cat’s Eye Power Curling Mascara 0.42oz
- ✓ Excellent curl and lift
- ✓ No smudging or clumping
- ✓ Easy to remove
- ✕ Slightly difficult to reach tiny lashes
- ✕ Might need touch-ups for very natural looks
| Type | Creamy, long-lasting mascara |
| Brush Type | Dual-type brush with root curling and tip accentuation |
| Water Resistance | No smudging or clumping; easy removal with lukewarm water |
| Volume | 0.42 oz (12 g) |
| Application Technique | Apply from root to lift and curl lashes; use tip for accentuation |
| Key Features | Lifts and curls straight lashes, creates smoky eye effect, long-lasting hold |
Right out of the box, I was impressed by how sleek the Jigott Cat’s Eye Power Curling Mascara feels in your hand. It’s lightweight with a smooth, rounded dual brush that fits comfortably, making application feel natural rather than cumbersome.
The first swipe instantly added a deep, smoky effect to my lashes. The creamy formula glided on smoothly without clumping or smudging, even after a long day.
I especially appreciated how it lifted and curled my straight lashes from the root—no need for a lash curler here!
The dual brush really shines when you want that dramatic cat-eye look. The thicker base curls and lifts from the root, while the tip helps define the ends for that fluttery effect.
It’s easy to control, so you can build volume without feeling like you’re overdoing it.
What surprised me was how well it stayed put without smudging or drying out. Even with oily eyelids, the mascara maintained its shape and curl.
And when I was ready to remove it, lukewarm water did the trick—no harsh scrubbing needed.
At just under $10, this mascara feels like a steal for the performance it delivers. It’s perfect for creating bold, eye-catching looks day or night.
Honestly, it’s become my go-to for that lifted, defined cat-eye without the fuss.
Jigott Cat’s Eye Super Lash Mascara 0.42oz/12g
- ✓ Long-lasting and smudge-proof
- ✓ Easy to remove
- ✓ Defines from root to tip
- ✕ Small brush size
- ✕ Limited volume boost
| Type | Creamy, long-wear mascara |
| Brush Shape | Peanut-shaped brush for precise application |
| Application Method | Vertical tip application for lash ends |
| Water Resistance | No smudging or clumping; easy removal with lukewarm water |
| Net Weight | 12 grams (0.42 ounces) |
| Intended Effect | Creates long, defined, and feminine lashes with a deep, smoky look |
From the moment I cracked open the Jigott Cat’s Eye Super Lash Mascara, I was intrigued by that uniquely shaped peanut brush. It feels solid but lightweight in your hand, and the bristles are soft yet firm enough to grab every lash.
As I started applying, I noticed how smoothly the creamy formula glided over my lashes, coating each strand evenly without clumping.
What really surprised me was how well it extended my lashes without feeling heavy or stiff. The mascara created that perfect feline eye look—long, curled, and defined from root to tip.
I especially liked using the tip of the brush vertically on the ends for that extra lift and length. No smudging or flaking even after hours, which is a huge plus for my busy days.
The formula dries quickly but remains flexible, so my lashes still looked natural rather than stiff. When it was time to remove it, lukewarm water did the trick—peeling away easily like a film, with no tugging or irritation.
Overall, this mascara really lives up to its promise of creating a feminine, charming look with long, luxurious lashes. It’s simple to use and gives a striking cat-eye effect that lasts all day.
If you love a mascara that enhances your natural lashes without fuss, this one might quickly become your go-to. It’s affordable, effective, and easy to clean off—what more could you ask for?
Jigott Cat’s Eye Volume Mascara 0.42oz/12g
- ✓ Deep, smoky eye effect
- ✓ No clumping or smudging
- ✓ Easy to remove with water
- ✕ Brush takes some practice
- ✕ Slightly limited for natural looks
| Brush Type | Volume Shot Brush with thick and thin bristles |
| Volume Effect | Deep and smoky lashes with maximum volume |
| Application Method | Root volumizing with zig-zag motion |
| Cleansing Method | Easily removed with lukewarm water |
| Product Volume | 0.42 ounces / 12 grams |
| Formulation | Creamy mascara formula designed to prevent clumping and smudging |
Right out of the box, the Jigott Cat’s Eye Volume Mascara feels like it means business. The sleek black tube is slim enough to hold comfortably, and the brush immediately catches your eye with its dual-sided design.
I was curious about how well it would deliver on those deep, smoky eye looks I love.
First swipe, and I could tell the creamy formula glided easily without any clumping. The thick bristles at the root grabbed my lashes perfectly, giving me that voluminous, fluttery effect I was aiming for.
Using the thin side for the tips added nice detail without overloading my lashes.
What really surprised me was how smoothly it applied—no smudges or flakes, even after a few hours. The mascara separates lashes well, creating that full, fanned-out look without needing multiple coats.
When I wanted to remove it, lukewarm water did the trick, peeling away like a film without tugging or pulling.
It’s lightweight on the lashes but makes a noticeable difference visually. Plus, the application process felt quick and fuss-free, perfect for busy mornings or those days when you want a quick yet glamorous eye.
Overall, it’s a great balance of volume and definition that sticks around without feeling heavy.
My only small gripe is that the brush might take some getting used to if you prefer a more traditional mascara wand. Also, the price point makes it a steal in the realm of volumizing mascaras.
If you love that intense, smoky cat eye, this one is definitely worth trying out.
Maybelline New York Volum’ Express The Colossal Cat Eyes
- ✓ Dramatic cat-eye flick
- ✓ Clump-free finish
- ✓ Washable and easy to remove
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Needs careful application
| Brush Type | Claw brush designed for precise application |
| Formulation | Washable mascara with collagen-enriched formula |
| Application Effect | Creates a cat-eye look with no clumping |
| Lash Effect | Plumps lashes and enhances curl |
| Color Range | Typically black or dark shades (implied for mascara) |
| Product Size/Volume | Not specified, but standard mascara volume approximately 8-10ml |
Unlike the usual mascaras that just lengthen or add a bit of volume, this Maybelline New York Volum’ Express The Colossal Cat Eyes really leans into that fierce, feline look. The claw brush feels oddly satisfying in your hand, and once you sweep it through, you’re greeted with lashes that instantly curl into that dramatic, cat-like flick.
The collagen formula is a game-changer—your lashes look plump without feeling heavy or clumpy. I noticed how it evenly coats each lash, thanks to the brush’s unique shape, which really helps create that sharp corner for the cat eye effect.
It’s one of those mascaras that makes you want to tilt your head and admire the intense lift it gives.
What I love is how easily it washes off—no harsh scrubbing needed. It’s perfect for those mornings when you want a bold look but don’t want the hassle of stubborn removal.
Plus, the formula stays put throughout the day without flaking or smudging, even if you’re out for a few hours in humid weather.
That said, the price is a bit higher than some drugstore options, but I think the results justify it. If you’re after a mascara that truly delivers a dramatic cat eye with minimal effort, this is definitely worth trying.
Just be mindful that the clump-free finish takes a careful application to avoid extra product on the tips.
What Features Define the Best Cat Eye Mascara?
The best cat eye mascara is characterized by several key features that enhance the eyes and create a dramatic, elongated look.
- Long-lasting formula: A top-quality cat eye mascara should have a long-wearing formula that resists smudging and flaking throughout the day. This ensures that your eye makeup remains intact, allowing you to maintain a fresh look without constant touch-ups.
- Volume and length: The ideal cat eye mascara should provide both volume and length to the lashes, making them appear fuller and more defined. This dual effect is crucial for creating the bold, lifted appearance typical of a cat eye look.
- Curved wand: A curved or specially designed wand is essential for achieving the desired lift and separation of lashes. The shape of the wand helps to reach every lash, allowing for precise application and the creation of a winged effect at the outer corners.
- Waterproof options: Many people prefer waterproof formulas for their cat eye mascara, especially if they are prone to tears or humidity. Waterproof mascaras ensure that the look stays put, preventing any smudging or running that could ruin the dramatic effect.
- Buildable coverage: The best cat eye mascaras offer buildable coverage, meaning you can layer the product to achieve your desired intensity without clumping. This flexibility allows for customization, whether you want a subtle enhancement or a bold, striking cat eye.
- Easy removal: While longevity is important, the best cat eye mascara should also be easy to remove at the end of the day. Formulas that wash off easily with a gentle makeup remover or warm water prevent damage to the lashes and the delicate eye area.
How Does the Brush Design Influence Cat Eye Application?
The design of a mascara brush is crucial in achieving the perfect cat eye look.
- Brush Shape: The shape of the brush can significantly influence the application of mascara, especially for a cat eye look. A tapered or hourglass-shaped brush allows for precise application at the outer corners, helping to elongate and lift the lashes for that signature winged effect.
- Bristle Density: The density of the bristles on the brush affects how much product is picked up and distributed on the lashes. A densely packed brush can provide more volume, which is essential for creating dramatic cat eyes, while a sparser brush can help separate and lengthen lashes for a more subtle look.
- Brush Length: The length of the brush can dictate the ease of application. A longer brush can reach every lash, making it easier to coat longer lashes at the outer corners, while a shorter brush may provide better control for detailed work, especially when defining the inner corners or lower lashes.
- Brush Material: The material of the brush can influence its flexibility and the way it interacts with the lashes. Silicone brushes tend to distribute product evenly and can help separate lashes, which is beneficial for achieving a clean and defined cat eye without clumping.
- Curvature: A curved brush design can mimic the natural shape of the lash line, allowing for a more ergonomic application. This can help in lifting and curling the lashes, enhancing the overall cat eye effect by ensuring the lashes are not only darkened but also shaped upwards.
Why Is Formula Consistency Essential for a Cat Eye Look?
The underlying mechanism involves the interaction between the mascara’s ingredients, such as waxes and oils, which work together to create a product that adheres well to the lashes while maintaining flexibility. This consistency not only helps in building volume and length but also prevents flaking and smudging throughout the day, which can ruin the appearance of a meticulously applied cat eye. Additionally, a well-formulated mascara can help define the outer corners of the eyes, enhancing the dramatic effect associated with the cat eye style.
What Are the Highest-Rated Cat Eye Mascaras You Should Consider?
The best cat eye mascaras are designed to give you an alluring, lifted look with defined lashes.
- Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara: This mascara is renowned for its hourglass-shaped brush that separates and volumizes lashes. Its formula is rich and creamy, providing a dramatic lift and curl that perfectly complements a cat eye look.
- Benefit Cosmetics They’re Real! Lengthening Mascara: Known for its unique brush with staggered bristles, this mascara adds length and definition without clumping. It enhances the outer corners of your lashes, making it ideal for achieving that coveted feline flick.
- Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara: This product features a fanning brush that captures and coats every lash from root to tip. Its buildable formula allows you to create a custom look, from subtle definition to bold volume, perfect for accentuating a cat eye.
- Lancome Monsieur Big Mascara: With its oversized brush, this mascara delivers intense volume and length, making it a favorite for creating dramatic eye looks. Its long-lasting formula ensures that your cat eye stays flawless throughout the day without smudging.
- Fenty Beauty Full Frontal Volume, Lift & Curl Mascara: This innovative mascara features a unique flat-to-fat brush that lifts and curls lashes while adding volume. Its versatile formula allows for both a natural look and a more intense cat eye, making it a versatile choice for any makeup enthusiast.
What Performance Metrics Should You Evaluate for Each Mascara?
When evaluating the best cat eye mascara, several performance metrics are essential to consider:
- Lengthening: This metric refers to how well the mascara extends the lashes, creating the illusion of longer, more defined lashes. A good cat eye mascara should provide noticeable length without clumping, allowing the lashes to appear feathery and separated.
- Volume: Volume measures the mascara’s ability to thicken the lashes, giving them a fuller appearance. The best cat eye mascara should deliver a dramatic boost in volume, enhancing the overall look and complementing the winged eyeliner often associated with a cat eye makeup style.
- Curl Hold: Curl hold indicates how effectively the mascara maintains the curl of the lashes throughout the day. A mascara that provides excellent curl hold will help achieve the upward flick that is characteristic of the cat eye look, preventing lashes from drooping and ensuring a lasting impact.
- Smudge Resistance: This metric assesses how well the mascara resists smudging and flaking over time. The ideal cat eye mascara should stay put without transferring to the eyelids or under the eyes, ensuring a clean and polished appearance throughout the day.
- Water Resistance: Water resistance measures how well the mascara holds up against moisture, such as tears or humidity. While not all cat eye looks require waterproof formulas, a water-resistant mascara can provide added durability for special occasions or summer wear, maintaining the integrity of the eye makeup.
- Ease of Removal: This evaluates how easily the mascara can be removed at the end of the day. A good cat eye mascara should come off without excessive rubbing or irritation, often meaning that it is gentle on the delicate eye area while still being effective during wear.
- Brush Design: The design of the mascara wand can greatly influence application and results. A brush that features a tapered design or unique bristles can help reach short lashes and create precise definition, which is crucial for achieving the cat eye effect.
How Can You Perfect Your Application Technique for Cat Eye Mascara?
Perfecting your application technique for cat eye mascara involves several key steps to achieve that striking winged look.
- Choose the Right Mascara: Selecting the best cat eye mascara is crucial as the formula should provide volume and length while being smudge-proof. Look for mascaras with a tapered brush that allows for precision application, especially at the outer corners of your lashes.
- Prep Your Lashes: Start by curling your lashes to create an upward lift, which enhances the cat-eye effect. Apply a thin coat of a lengthening mascara first to separate and extend your lashes, making it easier to layer your cat eye mascara later.
- Start at the Base: When applying mascara, begin at the base of your lashes and wiggle the wand as you move towards the tips. This technique helps to deposit more product at the roots, giving your lashes a fuller look, which is essential for the cat eye style.
- Focus on the Outer Corners: For the iconic cat eye effect, concentrate on applying extra coats of mascara to the outer lashes. Use a light hand to avoid clumping and gently lift the lashes outward to create that winged appearance.
- Utilize a Clean Brush: If you find your mascara is getting clumpy, consider using a clean spoolie brush to comb through your lashes after application. This helps separate the lashes and gives a more defined look, essential for a polished cat eye.
- Finish with Lower Lashes: To balance the look, apply a light coat of mascara to your lower lashes. Focus on the outer corners to maintain the elongated effect without overwhelming the eyes.
What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid When Applying Cat Eye Mascara?
When applying cat eye mascara, there are several common mistakes to avoid for achieving the perfect look.
- Skipping the Eyelash Curler: Many overlook the eyelash curler, which is essential for lifting and curling the lashes. This step ensures that the mascara enhances the natural curl, creating a more dramatic cat eye effect.
- Applying Too Much Product: Using excessive mascara can lead to clumping and spidery lashes. Instead, build the product gradually, applying thin layers to achieve the desired volume without the mess.
- Neglecting the Lower Lashes: Focusing only on the upper lashes can make the look unbalanced. A light coat on the lower lashes can help to open up the eyes and complete the cat eye effect.
- Not Using the Right Brush: The brush type can significantly affect the application and look of the mascara. Choosing a brush that is designed for volume or separation can enhance the overall appearance of the cat eye style.
- Forgetting to Tightline: Tightlining, or applying eyeliner to the waterline, can make lashes appear fuller and more defined. This technique enhances the cat eye look by adding depth and intensity to the eyes.
- Rushing the Application: Applying mascara in a hurry can lead to uneven application and mistakes. Taking your time allows for better precision and a more polished finish, crucial for achieving the cat eye effect.