best mascara for cat eye

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Imagine trying to master the perfect cat eye, only to be frustrated by smudging or uneven lashes. I’ve tested tons of mascaras, and the one that truly stood out is the Maybelline New York Volum’ Express The Colossal Cat Eyes. Its collagen formula and claw brush create instant volume and sharp corners, making that feline flick easier and more precise than ever. When I used it, my lashes looked bold and lifted, with no clumps or smudges, even after hours.

Compared to other options, like the Jigott mascaras, which excel in curling and lengthening, this Maybelline product offers a perfect balance of volume and definition, especially for a dramatic cat eye. It’s washable, easy to remove, and delivers consistent results. If you want a reliable, high-impact finish that really makes your eyes pop without fuss, this mascara is the way to go. Trust me—after testing all these formulas, this one stays on top for style and durability.

Top Recommendation: Maybelline New York Volum’ Express The Colossal Cat Eyes

Why We Recommend It: This mascara combines a collagen-enriched formula with a claw brush that plumps lashes and creates sharp, cat-like corners. It offers bold volume and long-lasting precision, standing out from curl-focused options like Jigott’s mascaras. Its washable formula ensures easy removal without sacrificing staying power, making it ideal for daily wear or special occasions.

Best mascara for cat eye: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewMaybelline Colossal Cat Eyes Washable Mascara 0.31 Fl OzJigott Cat's Eye Power Curling Mascara 0.42ozJigott Cat's Eye Super Lash Mascara 0.42oz/12g
TitleMaybelline Colossal Cat Eyes Washable Mascara 0.31 Fl OzJigott Cat’s Eye Power Curling Mascara 0.42ozJigott Cat’s Eye Super Lash Mascara 0.42oz/12g
TypeWashable MascaraCurling MascaraLash Extending Mascara
Brush TypeClaw brushDual type brushPeanut shape brush
Lash EffectVolume with cat-like cornersLift and curl, long-lastingLong and luxurious lashes
Formula CharacteristicsCollagen formulaCreamy, smudge-proof, clump-freeCreamy, smudge-proof, clump-free
Ease of RemovalEasy cleansing with lukewarm waterEasy cleansing with lukewarm waterEasy cleansing with lukewarm water
Size0.31 Fl Oz0.42 oz0.42 oz
PriceUSD 6.96USD 9.99USD 9.99
Available

Maybelline Colossal Cat Eyes Washable Mascara 0.31 Fl Oz

Maybelline Colossal Cat Eyes Washable Mascara 0.31 Fl Oz
Pros:
  • Creates bold, winged corners
  • Builds volume without clumping
  • Easy to remove
Cons:
  • May require multiple coats
  • Claw brush takes some getting used to
Specification:
Brush Type Claw brush designed for volumizing and defining lashes
Formula Collagen-infused formula for lash plumping and spike effect
Volume Provides colossal volume with a focus on creating cat-like corners
Application Type Washable mascara for easy removal
Net Volume 0.31 fluid ounces (9.2 milliliters)
Intended Effect Enhances lash volume and shape for a cat-eye look

The first thing that hits you when you unbox the Maybelline Colossal Cat Eyes Mascara is its bold, sleek black tube. It feels sturdy yet lightweight in your hand, and the claw-shaped brush instantly catches your eye.

You can tell this mascara was designed for precision, especially if you’re aiming for that iconic cat-eye flick.

Applying it is surprisingly smooth. The claw brush catches every lash, coating them evenly without clumping.

I noticed right away how the collagen formula thickened my lashes, giving them a plush, voluminous look. The formula feels slightly gel-like, which helps spike out your lashes without weighing them down.

What really sets this mascara apart is how effortlessly it creates those sharp, winged corners. You can easily build up to a dramatic look, thanks to the flexible brush.

Plus, it stays put through the day without smudging or flaking, which is a huge bonus for busy mornings.

Removal is simple, too—just a little warm water and gentle pressure. It washes off cleanly without tugging or pulling at your lashes.

Over extended use, I found it keeps lashes feeling healthy, not brittle or dry. Overall, it’s a fun, effective mascara that delivers on volume and that perfect cat-eye shape.

Jigott Cat’s Eye Power Curling Mascara 0.42oz

Jigott Cat
Pros:
  • Long-lasting curl and lift
  • No smudging or clumping
  • Easy to remove with water
Cons:
  • Slightly heavy for sensitive eyes
  • Might be too dramatic for everyday
Specification:
Type Creamy, long-wash mascara with curling and lifting properties
Brush Type Dual-type brush designed for root curling and lash accentuation
Water Resistance No smudging or clumping, easily removable with lukewarm water
Volume 0.42 ounces (12 grams)
Application Features Separates lashes, creates deep smoky eye effect, maintains curl and lift over time
Key Benefits Long-lasting curl, easy removal, smudge-proof, clump-free

The first thing you’ll notice when you pick up the Jigott Cat’s Eye Power Curling Mascara is its dual-type brush. It’s chunky and has a unique shape that feels substantial in your hand, making it easy to grip and maneuver.

This mascara’s real magic shows when you start applying. The creamy formula glides smoothly, coating each lash evenly without clumping or smudging.

I was impressed how it instantly lifted my straight lashes, curling them from the root and holding that curl for hours.

The dual brush design is a game-changer. The thicker side powerfully curls and lifts, while the tip allows you to target specific lashes for that dramatic cat-eye effect.

It’s perfect if you want a bold, smoky look that stays put without flaking or smudging.

What I really appreciated is how easy it was to clean off with lukewarm water. No harsh scrubbing needed.

It gently separates from your lashes like a film, which means no tugging or irritation.

In terms of wear, I found it lasted all day without drooping or fading. That’s a huge plus if you want your eyes to stay fierce from morning to night.

Plus, at just under ten dollars, it’s a pretty affordable way to elevate your eye game.

Of course, if you prefer a more natural look or have very sensitive eyes, this might be a bit heavy or overwhelming. But overall, it’s a reliable choice for anyone aiming for that perfect, long-lasting cat-eye.

Jigott Cat’s Eye Super Lash Mascara 0.42oz/12g

Jigott Cat
Pros:
  • Long, defined lashes
  • No clumping or smudging
  • Easy to remove
Cons:
  • Limited color options
  • May need multiple coats for extra volume
Specification:
Lash Length Extended for a long and luxurious look
Mascara Formula Creamy, smudge-proof, and clump-free
Brush Shape Peanut-shaped for precise application
Application Method Vertical tip for lash tips and thorough coverage
Cleansing Method Easy removal with lukewarm water
Product Volume 0.42 oz / 12 g

Most people assume that creating a perfect cat-eye look with mascara is all about the eyeliner, but honestly, a good mascara can make all the difference. The Jigott Cat’s Eye Super Lash Mascara proved that to me the moment I swiped it on—my lashes instantly looked longer and more defined.

The unique peanut-shaped brush is a game-changer. It coats every lash from root to tip, even those tiny inner corner hairs that are usually hard to grab.

I loved how easily it separated my lashes without clumping or smudging, which is rare for mascaras that claim to lengthen.

The creamy formula glides on smoothly, giving my lashes a deep, smoky effect that really enhances my eye shape. I didn’t need to layer it multiple times—one or two coats were enough for a dramatic, feminine look.

And the best part? It dries quickly and stays put without flaking or smudging, even after a few hours of wear.

When I wanted to remove it, a quick splash of lukewarm water did the trick. The mascara peeled away like a film, no harsh scrubbing needed.

For anyone who loves that long, feminine lash look with a precise cat-eye vibe, this mascara really delivers.

At just $9.99, it feels like a steal for such a high-quality product. It makes achieving that perfect, eye-opening look effortless, whether for everyday wear or a night out.

Jigott Cat’s Eye Volume Mascara 0.42oz/12g

Jigott Cat
Pros:
  • Easy to remove with warm water
  • Builds volume without clumping
  • Perfect for dramatic looks
Cons:
  • Might need multiple coats for subtlety
  • Can be too intense for everyday wear
Specification:
Brush Type Volume Shot Brush with thick and thin bristles
Volume Designed to create maximum lash volume from the root
Application Method Zig-zag motion from lash roots for volumizing and separation
Water Solubility Removable with lukewarm water, film-forming removal
Product Size 0.42 oz / 12 g
Color Range Not specified, typically black for mascara

As soon as I dip the Jigott Cat’s Eye Volume Mascara brush into the tube, I notice how creamy and rich the formula feels. It glides onto my lashes effortlessly, coating each strand without clumping or smudging, which is a game-changer for creating that deep, smoky eye look.

The volume shot brush is cleverly designed with thick bristles at the root and thinner ones for detailed work. When I press the brush at my lash roots and zig-zag upward, my lashes instantly look thicker and more defined.

The thick bristles really grab and volumize from the base, giving that dramatic cat-eye effect I love.

What surprised me is how easily it cleans off with lukewarm water. It peels away like a film, leaving my lashes feeling soft and free of residue.

No harsh scrubbing needed, which is perfect for my sensitive eyes. Plus, the mascara stays put throughout the day without any smudging or flaking.

Trying to build up more volume just involves multiple coats, but the formula remains smooth and doesn’t get clumpy. The pigmentation is intense, making my lashes stand out even more.

The only thing is, for a super natural look, you might need to be careful not to over-apply.

Overall, this mascara is a solid pick for anyone wanting that bold, cat-eye glam. It’s easy to work with, lasts all day, and washes off gently.

Plus, at under $10, it’s a great value for such a versatile product.

Maybelline New York Volum’ Express The Colossal Cat Eyes

Maybelline New York Volum
Pros:
  • Clump-free volume
  • Precise claw brush
  • Washable and easy removal
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Not waterproof
Specification:
Brush Type Claw brush designed for precise application and creating cat-eye flicks
Formula Type Washable mascara with collagen-enriched formula
Lash Effect Plumps lashes and creates a bold, cat-like corner look
Finish No clumpy finish for a smooth, defined appearance
Suitable for Achieving a wild, dramatic cat eye look
Price USD 21.7

The first time I swiped on Maybelline’s New York Volum’ Express The Colossal Cat Eyes, I was surprised by how effortlessly it created that sharp, feline flick right at the corner of my eye. The claw brush felt sturdy in my hand, and I remember thinking how precise I could get with it—no smudges or accidental smears.

The collagen formula gave my lashes a noticeable plumpness, making my eyes look more awake and expressive instantly.

What really caught my attention was how well it built up volume without getting clumpy. Usually, with mascaras that aim for a dramatic cat-eye effect, I worry about clumps, but this one stayed smooth and separated.

The brush’s unique shape helps you extend those outer corners, giving me that perfect, fierce look I was after. Plus, the washable formula means it’s easy to remove at night without tugging or rubbing too much.

Applying it felt like a breeze; the formula isn’t too wet or too dry, so I could layer it without worrying about it flaking or settling into my fine lines. I even tried it on a day when I wanted a more natural look, and it still held up well—no smudging or fading.

Overall, it’s a solid choice if you’re after a mascara that can give you that bold, cat-eye finish with a clean, no-clump look.

It’s a bit on the pricier side at $21.70, but considering how well it performs, I think it’s worth the investment. Just keep in mind, if you’re after a super dramatic, waterproof look, this might not be the best fit.

But if you want a versatile, easy-to-use mascara that makes your eyes pop like a sleek feline, this one’s a winner.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment