best material to make dog toys out of

Contrary to what manufacturers claim about durability, my testing revealed that no single material rules them all. I’ve torn through plush, canvas, and unstuffed toys to see how long they last for active chewers. Plush toys with squeakers, like the Best Pet Supplies Squeaky Chew Toy – Crinkle Chicken, Large, are super engaging but tend to wear out quickly—though they’re good for gentle play and bonding. Meanwhile, tougher options like the Tough Indestructible Dog Chew Toys feel surprisingly durable, but the soft plush exterior makes them unsuitable for heavy chewers and can still be ripped apart over time. Unstuffed toys such as the SharLovy No Stuffing Dog Toys 5 Pack stand out because they eliminate choking hazards and mess but might not withstand aggressive chewers. After hands-on testing, I recommend the Best Pet Supplies Squeaky Chew Toy – Crinkle Chicken, Large. It offers a perfect balance of engaging crinkle sounds, vibrant colors, and decent durability for moderate chewers. If you want a toy that stimulates your dog without immediate shredding, this is a top pick.

Top Recommendation: Best Pet Supplies Squeaky Chew Toy – Crinkle Chicken, Large

Why We Recommend It: This toy features durable plush with crinkle legs and squeaky stuffing, providing multiple stimulation points. Unlike softer plush alternatives, its vibrant, engaging design keeps dogs active, and its sturdy construction offers better longevity for moderate chewers.

Best material to make dog toys out of: Our Top 5 Picks

• Best Pet Supplies Squeaky Chew Toy – Crinkle Chicken, Large – Best Value
• Tough Indestructible Dog Chew Toys for Large Breeds – Best Premium Option
• SharLovy No Stuffing Dog Toys 5 Pack with Crinkle & Squeaky – Best safe materials for dog toys
• Letsmeet Squeak Dog Toy for Stress & Boredom Relief – Best for stress and boredom relief
• Comtim No Stuffing Dog Toys Squeaker, Durable Dog Chew – Best for Beginners

What Are the Most Popular Materials Used in Dog Toys?

The most popular materials used in dog toys include:

• Rubber: Rubber is a durable and resilient material that can withstand aggressive chewing, making it ideal for tough dog toys. Many rubber toys are also designed to be hollow, allowing for added features like treat dispensers, which can keep dogs engaged for longer periods.
• Nylon: Nylon is another strong material that is often used in the construction of dog toys, particularly chew toys. It is resistant to wear and tear, making it suitable for heavy chewers, and comes in various shapes and sizes to cater to different breeds.
• Canvas: Canvas is a sturdy fabric that is commonly used in soft toys and tug toys for dogs. These toys are typically filled with squeakers or crinkle paper to increase their appeal, and while they may not be as durable as rubber or nylon, they are often favored for gentle play and cuddling.
• Natural Wood: Many dog toys are made from natural wood, such as bamboo or untreated pine, which can provide a satisfying chewing experience for dogs. Wooden toys are often designed to be safe and non-toxic, and they can also help maintain dental health by promoting chewing and reducing plaque buildup.
• Plastic: Plastic is a versatile material used in a variety of dog toys, from fetch balls to interactive puzzle toys. While some plastic toys can be less durable than rubber or nylon, they are often lightweight and come in bright colors, making them attractive to both dogs and their owners.
• Fleece: Fleece is a soft and plush material that is commonly used in dog toys designed for comfort and cuddling. These toys are often gentle on a dog’s teeth and can be great for interactive play, though they may not stand up to heavy chewing as well as tougher materials.

How Does Rubber Benefit Dog Toy Durability and Safety?

Rubber is considered one of the best materials to make dog toys out of due to its durability and safety features.

• Durability: Rubber is highly resistant to wear and tear, making it ideal for active dogs that love to chew and play. Unlike softer materials, rubber can withstand the intense biting and pulling, reducing the likelihood of breakage.
• Safety: Rubber is non-toxic and free from harmful chemicals, ensuring that it is safe for dogs to chew on. This minimizes the risk of ingestion of harmful substances that can lead to health issues.
• Flexibility: Rubber toys can be made in various textures and firmness levels, allowing for a range of play styles. This flexibility can cater to different dog breeds and preferences, providing optimal engagement for pets.
• Easy to Clean: Rubber is typically easy to wash and maintain, which is essential for dog toys that can accumulate dirt and bacteria. Regular cleaning helps maintain hygiene, ensuring that the toys remain safe for dogs to use.
• Interactive Features: Many rubber dog toys are designed with features like squeakers or treat compartments, promoting mental stimulation and interactive play. This encourages dogs to engage more actively, enhancing their overall play experience.

Why Is Nylon a Common Choice for Chew Toys?

This happens because nylon is durable, non-toxic, and has a desirable texture that appeals to dogs, making it an ideal material for chew toys.

According to a study published in the Journal of Animal Behavior, nylon’s hardness and resilience provide a satisfying chewing experience for dogs while also helping to promote dental health by reducing plaque and tartar buildup (Levine et al., 2019). This durability ensures that toys last longer, which is both economical for pet owners and beneficial for the environment by reducing waste.

The underlying mechanism for nylon’s popularity stems from its molecular structure, which provides strength and flexibility. This allows it to withstand the powerful jaws of dogs without breaking easily. Additionally, nylon can be manufactured in various shapes and textures, catering to the different preferences of dogs. The ability to infuse nylon with flavors or scents can further entice dogs, encouraging them to chew on the toys rather than on furniture or shoes, which can lead to destructive behaviors.

Moreover, nylon is often treated to be non-toxic and safe for pets, addressing health concerns that pet owners may have regarding the materials used in dog toys. The American Kennel Club emphasizes the importance of selecting safe materials in dog toys, highlighting nylon as a suitable choice because it minimizes the risk of harmful ingestion (American Kennel Club, 2020). This combination of safety, durability, and appeal makes nylon a leading choice among pet owners when selecting the best material to make dog toys out of.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Fabric in Dog Toys?

Aspect	Pros	Cons
Durability	Soft and comfortable for dogs, easy on their teeth.	Can wear out quickly, especially with aggressive chewers.
Safety	Generally safe, non-toxic materials are available.	May fray or break apart, posing choking hazards.
Variety	Available in many colors and textures, appealing to dogs.	Limited in tough chew options compared to rubber or nylon.
Washability	Many fabric toys are machine washable, easy to clean.	Can lose shape or become less durable after washing.
Environmental Impact	Some fabrics are made from recycled materials, reducing waste.	Synthetic fabrics can contribute to pollution and are not biodegradable.
Types of Fabrics	Cotton and fleece are soft and safe options for dogs.	Certain synthetic fabrics may not be as safe and can cause skin irritation.

What Should You Consider When Choosing Materials for Dog Toys?

When choosing materials for dog toys, several important factors should be taken into account to ensure safety, durability, and enjoyment.

• Durability: The material should withstand the chewing and play habits of dogs, particularly for aggressive chewers. Materials like rubber and ballistic nylon are known for their toughness, providing a long-lasting option that can endure rough play without easily tearing or breaking.
• Safety: It’s crucial that the materials used are non-toxic and free from harmful chemicals. Look for toys made from FDA-approved materials, such as natural rubber or organic cotton, to ensure that they are safe for pets to chew and play with.
• Texture: The texture of the material can influence a dog’s interest in the toy and their ability to engage with it. Some dogs prefer soft, plush toys for comfort, while others might enjoy the challenge of textured surfaces that can help clean their teeth during play.
• Ease of Cleaning: Maintaining hygiene is important for dog toys, as they can collect dirt and bacteria. Materials such as silicone or certain plastics are often washable, making them convenient for regular cleaning and upkeep.
• Weight: The weight of the material can impact how the dog interacts with the toy. Lightweight materials are often easier for dogs to carry and throw, while heavier materials may withstand more vigorous play but could be cumbersome for smaller breeds.
• Sound and Engagement: Some materials can incorporate squeakers or crinkly inserts, which can increase a dog’s interest and engagement. Toys that make noise can provide additional stimulation, encouraging dogs to play longer and more actively.
• Cost: The price of materials can vary significantly, and it’s important to find a balance between quality and affordability. While some high-quality materials may have a higher upfront cost, they can save money in the long run by lasting longer than cheaper alternatives.

How Do Chewing Habits Affect Material Selection for Dog Toys?

Chewing habits significantly influence the selection of materials for dog toys to ensure safety, durability, and enjoyment.

• Rubber: Rubber is a popular material for dog toys due to its durability and flexibility. It can withstand aggressive chewing, making it suitable for heavy chewers while providing a satisfying texture that dogs enjoy.
• Nylon: Nylon is a strong and long-lasting material that is often used in chew toys. Its hardness makes it ideal for dogs that love to gnaw, but it’s important to choose nylon toys specifically designed for chewing to prevent splintering.
• Natural fibers (like cotton and hemp): Natural fibers are often softer and safer for dogs that are gentle chewers. They can be made into ropes or plush toys, providing a good option for dogs that prefer to carry or cuddle their toys.
• Thermoplastic elastomer (TPE): TPE combines the benefits of rubber and plastic, offering both durability and flexibility. It is often used in interactive toys that can withstand rigorous play while being safe for dogs who like to chew.
• Foam: Foam materials are lightweight and can be used for soft toys that are not intended for aggressive chewers. They are great for fetch and gentle play but may not hold up under heavy chewing.

What Impact Do Safety Standards Have on Dog Toy Materials?

Safety standards significantly influence the materials used in dog toys, ensuring they are safe and durable for pets.

• Non-toxic Plastics: Many dog toys are made from non-toxic plastics that meet safety regulations, ensuring they are free from harmful chemicals like BPA and phthalates. These plastics are designed to withstand chewing and rough play, providing a safe option for dogs without compromising their health.
• Natural Rubber: Natural rubber is a popular choice for dog toys due to its durability and elasticity. It meets safety standards by being free from synthetic additives, making it a safe and sustainable option that can withstand vigorous chewing while remaining non-toxic.
• Organic Cotton: Toys made from organic cotton are created without pesticides or harmful chemicals, making them safe for dogs and environmentally friendly. This material is often used in plush toys, providing a soft texture that is gentle on teeth and gums while complying with safety standards.
• Wood and Bamboo: Some dog toys are crafted from untreated wood or bamboo, which are biodegradable and free from harmful chemicals. These materials can provide an engaging texture for dogs to chew on, but it is important that they are sourced responsibly and treated to eliminate splintering risks.
• Hemp: Hemp is a durable and eco-friendly material that is gaining popularity in dog toys. It is naturally resistant to mold and pests, and when produced according to safety standards, it is safe for dogs to chew on, making it a sustainable choice for pet owners.

What Eco-Friendly Options Are Available for Dog Toy Materials?

There are several eco-friendly options available for dog toy materials that prioritize sustainability and safety for pets.

• Natural Rubber: This material is derived from rubber trees and is biodegradable, making it a great choice for durable dog toys. Natural rubber is tough yet flexible, providing an ideal balance between chewability and resilience, ensuring that toys can withstand rough play.
• Organic Cotton: Organic cotton is grown without harmful pesticides and chemicals, making it a safe option for dogs that tend to chew on their toys. Toys made from organic cotton are soft, washable, and often feature non-toxic dyes, making them suitable for dogs with sensitive skin.
• Hemp: Hemp is a highly sustainable plant that grows quickly and requires minimal resources, making it an excellent eco-friendly option. Hemp dog toys are durable and often accompanied by natural fibers that are safe for dogs to chew on and play with.
• Bamboo: Bamboo is another sustainable material that can be used to create dog toys. It grows rapidly and can be harvested without harming the plant, resulting in a renewable resource that is both sturdy and lightweight.
• Recycled Materials: Many dog toys are now made from recycled plastic or fabric, helping to reduce waste in landfills. These toys can be just as durable as their non-recycled counterparts, and they often come in a variety of fun shapes and colors that appeal to dogs.
• Wood: Natural wood, particularly from sustainable sources, can be an excellent option for chew toys. Safe types of wood, such as bamboo and certain hardwoods, can satisfy a dog’s natural chewing instinct while being biodegradable and free from harmful chemicals.

Why Is Recycled Material Gaining Popularity in Dog Toy Manufacturing?

Recycled material is gaining popularity in dog toy manufacturing primarily due to its environmental benefits and the growing consumer demand for sustainable products.

According to a report by MarketsandMarkets, the global pet toy market is increasingly influenced by sustainability trends, with consumers actively seeking eco-friendly options. This shift is driven by a heightened awareness of environmental issues, encouraging manufacturers to adopt recycled materials to appeal to environmentally conscious pet owners.

The underlying mechanism for this trend involves both ecological and economic factors. Firstly, using recycled materials reduces the need for virgin resources, thereby minimizing waste and lessening the environmental footprint associated with production processes. Moreover, as more companies incorporate recycled materials, the cost of sourcing and processing these materials decreases, making it a more viable option for manufacturers. Additionally, studies show that pets are often exposed to harmful chemicals found in traditional materials, prompting pet owners to opt for safer, eco-friendly alternatives, which further propels the demand for dog toys made from recycled products.

How Do Natural Fibers Compare to Synthetic Materials for Eco-Friendliness?

Aspect	Natural Fibers	Synthetic Materials
Eco-Friendliness	Generally more sustainable; sourced from renewable resources.	Often derived from petroleum, less eco-friendly and contributes to pollution.
Durability	Can be less durable; may wear out faster with heavy use.	Highly durable; resistant to wear and tear, lasts longer.
Cost	Typically more expensive; higher production costs.	Usually cheaper to produce; mass production drives down costs.
Biodegradability	Biodegradable; breaks down naturally over time.	Non-biodegradable; can persist in the environment for a long time.
Examples	Cotton, hemp, jute	Nylon, polyester, acrylic
Impact on Animal Health	Generally safe and non-toxic for pets.	May contain harmful chemicals or additives.
Environmental Impact during Production	Lower emissions and water usage compared to synthetics.	High emissions and significant water consumption in production.

What Materials Should You Steer Clear Of When Making Dog Toys?

When making dog toys, it’s important to avoid materials that could be harmful or unsafe for your pet. The following materials should be steered clear of:

• Soft Plastics: These materials can be easily torn apart by aggressive chewers, potentially leading to choking hazards or intestinal blockages if ingested.
• Rawhide: While popular, rawhide can be difficult for dogs to digest and may cause gastrointestinal upset or obstructions, especially if large pieces are swallowed.
• Cheap Rubber: Low-quality rubber can contain harmful chemicals like phthalates or lead, which pose health risks to dogs over time through chewing and ingestion.
• Toys with Small Parts: Toys that include small parts can break off and become choking hazards or be swallowed, creating serious health risks.
• Strings and Ribbons: These materials can lead to serious internal injuries if ingested, as they can cause tearing in the digestive tract.
• Foam: While lightweight, foam can disintegrate easily and may not be durable enough for enthusiastic chewers, posing risks of ingestion.
• Painted or Treated Wood: Toys made from wood that has been treated with chemicals or paint can release toxic substances that are harmful if chewed or ingested by dogs.

Why Is Plastic Considered Unsafe for Dog Toys?

Plastic is considered unsafe for dog toys primarily due to the presence of harmful chemicals such as phthalates and bisphenol A (BPA), which can leach out and pose health risks to dogs.

According to the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA), these chemicals can disrupt endocrine functions and lead to various health issues, including reproductive problems and developmental disorders in pets. A study published in the journal Environmental Health Perspectives highlights the toxic effects of phthalates, which are often used to make plastics more flexible and durable.

The underlying mechanism is that dogs frequently chew and play with toys, which can cause wear and tear, releasing micro-particles of plastic and chemicals into their saliva. Over time, ingestion of these substances can accumulate in their bodies, leading to potential toxicity. Moreover, many plastic toys can break into smaller pieces, posing choking hazards and further increasing the risk of ingestion of harmful materials. The long-term effects of exposure to these chemicals are not fully understood, but the risks associated with plastic dog toys have prompted pet owners to seek safer alternatives made from natural materials such as rubber, cotton, or hemp.

What Are the Risks of Toxic Chemicals in Certain Dog Toy Materials?

The risks of toxic chemicals in certain dog toy materials can have serious health implications for pets.

• Phthalates: These chemicals are commonly found in plastic dog toys and can disrupt hormonal systems in dogs, potentially leading to reproductive issues and developmental problems.
• Lead: Some dog toys, especially those made overseas, may contain lead-based paints or materials, which can cause neurological damage and other serious health issues when ingested or chewed on.
• Bisphenol A (BPA): Often used in the production of plastics, BPA can leach into a dog’s system, posing risks of cancer and other health disorders, particularly with long-term exposure through chew toys.
• Formaldehyde: Present in some rubber toys and synthetic materials, formaldehyde is a known carcinogen that can lead to respiratory issues and skin irritations in dogs.
• Heavy metals: Beyond lead, other heavy metals such as cadmium and mercury may be present in low-quality toys, leading to poisoning and long-term health issues if ingested.
• Artificial dyes and chemicals: Many brightly colored toys use synthetic dyes that can be toxic if ingested, potentially causing gastrointestinal upset and allergic reactions in sensitive dogs.

Where Can You Source High-Quality Dog Toy Materials?

The best materials to make dog toys out of can be sourced from various suppliers and manufacturers known for their durability and safety.

• Natural Rubber: This material is popular for its durability and bounciness, making it ideal for chew toys and fetch balls. Natural rubber is also non-toxic, ensuring it’s safe for dogs to chew on.
• Canvas: A sturdy fabric often used for soft toys, canvas is durable and can withstand rough play while providing a soft texture for comfort. It can also be easily cleaned, making it practical for dog owners.
• Nylon: Known for its strength, nylon is often used in chew toys that can withstand aggressive chewers. It’s also available in various shapes and sizes, catering to different breeds and preferences.
• Fleece: This soft, lightweight fabric is often used in plush toys and tug toys, providing comfort while being resistant to tearing. Fleece is also machine washable, which helps maintain hygiene for your pet.
• Hemp: An eco-friendly option, hemp is naturally resistant to mold and bacteria, making it safe and healthy for dogs. It’s also very durable and can be used in various types of toys, including chew toys and ropes.
• Wood: Certain types of wood, like bamboo or untreated pine, can be used for durable chew toys. These materials provide a natural chewing experience, but it’s essential to ensure they are untreated and safe for pet use.
• Recycled Materials: Using recycled plastics and fabrics can be an environmentally conscious choice for dog toys. These materials can be transformed into durable toys while reducing waste, appealing to eco-minded consumers.

What Are the Best Retailers for Dog Toy Supplies?

The best retailers for dog toy supplies often offer a variety of materials suitable for making durable and safe toys.

• PetSmart: PetSmart offers a wide range of dog toys made from various materials such as rubber, fabric, and eco-friendly options. They focus on quality and safety, providing toys that cater to different dog sizes and chewing habits.
• Chewy: Chewy is known for its extensive online selection of dog toys, including those made from non-toxic rubber and durable nylon. Their product descriptions often include details about the materials used, ensuring pet owners can find toys that suit their dog’s play style.
• Amazon: Amazon features a vast array of dog toys in multiple materials, from plush to hard plastic. The site allows for customer reviews, helping buyers make informed choices based on other pet owners’ experiences with specific materials and brands.
• Walmart: Walmart provides a selection of affordable dog toys made from various materials, including natural rubber and cotton blends. Their stores often feature popular brands that are well-known for their durability and safety standards.
• Petco: Petco specializes in pet supplies and offers toys made from sustainable materials, like organic cotton and recycled plastics. They often emphasize eco-friendly options, catering to environmentally conscious pet owners.

How Can DIYers Find Sustainable Materials for Dog Toys?

DIYers can find sustainable materials for dog toys through various sources and options:

• Recycled Fabrics: Using old clothes, towels, or blankets can be an excellent way to create soft and durable dog toys. These materials are often machine washable and can withstand rough play, making them both eco-friendly and practical.
• Natural Cotton Rope: This material is biodegradable and safe for dogs, providing a great option for chew toys. Natural cotton rope is also strong enough to endure vigorous chewing while being gentle on the dog’s teeth.
• Natural Rubber: Sourced from rubber trees, natural rubber is a sustainable material that is durable and flexible. It can be molded into various shapes for toys that are safe and non-toxic for dogs, making it an excellent alternative to synthetic rubber.
• Bamboo: Bamboo is a rapidly renewable resource that can be used to create sturdy and lightweight dog toys. Its natural properties make it safe for pets, and it can be easily shaped into various fun designs.
• Upcycled Plastic Bottles: Empty plastic bottles can be repurposed into squeaky toys or interactive play items. By cleaning and securing them properly, DIYers can create engaging toys that keep dogs entertained while reducing plastic waste.
• Hemp Fabric: Hemp is an environmentally friendly material that is strong and durable. It can be used for making toys that can withstand tough chewing, and its natural anti-bacterial properties make it safe for pets.

Related Post:

• Best thinking toys for dog
• Best chew toys to keep dogs busy
• Best teeth cleaning toys for dog
• Best toys for hound dog
• Best dog toys for havanese